When the trial keeps getting extended

The free pilot will not convert. What to ask before the next extension.

A free pilot has a cost. It is simply paid by the wrong side of the table.

Every free extension is a commitment from your team and a deferral from theirs. The user's enthusiasm is real, and it has no signing authority. Nothing about another month changes who can say yes.

Before you approve the next extension, write the name of the person who can sign and the date they will be asked. If you cannot fill in either, the extension is a gift rather than a sales step.

What just happened

Another positive update from the team using the software. A few helpful suggestions. A request to extend the free pilot while the internal discussion continues.

Your developer spent most of last week on pilot requests. Someone in your own team called them a customer. You still have not met the person who can authorise payment.

What you are probably about to do

They love it, they just don't have budget yet.
  • Add the requested improvements.
  • Extend one more month.
  • Wait for the next budget cycle.
  • Keep the relationship warm and avoid the price conversation.

Why that does not settle it

More of the same usage produces more of the same answer. A pilot with no end date, no named budget owner, no written success criteria and no decision at the end is a free trial with better manners.

The fear is that asking for payment will end the relationship. The cost of not asking is that your team's capacity is being spent on a decision nobody at the customer has been asked to make. A no now is cheaper than a no after six months.

The question underneath

Who at this customer can become the paying customer, what triggers that purchase, and what has each of the user, the sponsor and the payer actually committed?

The GTM Right question this belongs to

Can a stranger become a paying customer?

Secondary: Can the wedge and channel sustain the motion?

Before you approve the next extension, this week

  1. 01

    Write three names: the person who uses it, the person who would sponsor the purchase internally, and the person who can sign. If the third name is blank, that is the finding.

  2. 02

    Write what each of the three has actually committed so far. Time and feedback are real; they are not budget.

  3. 03

    Reply to the extension request with a proposal: a meeting with the budget owner about a defined paid offer, and the conditions under which the pilot continues. If further trial work is needed, ask which decision it supports and who will evaluate the result.

  4. 04

    Tell your own team what the pilot is for before they spend another week on it. A pilot with a commercial purpose gets priority. A pilot without one gets a boundary.

Every free extension is a commitment from your team and a deferral from theirs.

Where GTM Right fits, and where it stops

In this situation the free Stage 1 check reads the public market evidence for the problem your software solves: whether teams at companies that have never seen it describe the problem as real, visible and urgent. That tells you whether the next pilot can be chosen on evidence rather than on who said yes. It does not answer the question in front of you this week, which is a question for the customer rather than for the market.

True Validation tests public market evidence only: whether the problem is real, visible and urgent. It does not prove buyer budget, willingness to pay, offer fit, acquisition economics or full commercial viability.

Buyer Precision is built around the buyer's ability to act, the purchase trigger and the buying context. Buyer + Offer then states the paid proposition and the proof needed to test willingness to pay. Together they give you a concrete buying proposition to take into the meeting, rather than another month of hoping.

Stages 2 to 6 test the later commercial assumptions: Buyer Precision, Buyer + Offer, Revenue Funnel, Market + Funnel, Commercial Decision. They do not change the fact that Stage 1 is market validation only.

Nothing here can make the customer buy, and nothing here can tell you what their budget owner will say. What it can do is make sure the next extension, if you grant one, has a named decision and a date attached to it.

Run the free Stage 1 check

Stage 1 of 6. Free. No account required. Usually under 90 seconds.

Questions founders ask in this situation

How do I turn a free pilot into a paid contract?
By agreeing, before or during the pilot, what result triggers a purchase, who signs it and when. Present the measured result to the budget owner against those criteria and ask for the decision. A pilot that was never scoped to end in a decision has to be re-scoped now, which is awkward, and still better than a seventh free month.
Why do companies keep extending the trial without buying?
Because extending costs them nothing and deciding costs them a conversation with whoever holds the budget. The person asking for the extension usually cannot buy; they can only keep using. Until someone with authority is asked a direct question, the path of least resistance is another month.
How do I find the budget owner behind an enthusiastic user?
Ask the user. A direct question, kindly put: if we moved to a paid agreement, who would need to approve it, and what would they need to see? The answer tells you the name, the internal case that has to be made, and whether your champion has ever raised it. Often they have not, and that is useful to know.
What should I agree before starting another free pilot?
An end date, written success criteria, the name of the person who decides at the end, and what a successful result leads to. Some teams also ask for a nominal payment, because what is paid for is taken seriously. A pilot without those four things is support work you have chosen to give away.
How do I test whether a pilot customer will actually pay?
Put a defined paid offer in front of the person who can sign, with a date for their answer. Their response is the evidence. A user's enthusiasm, however sincere, is evidence about the product's usefulness, not about the purchase.
When should I stop supporting a pilot that is not converting?
When you have asked the budget owner for a decision and either received a no or cannot get the question in front of them. At that point continued support is a cost with no commercial purpose. Set a boundary, thank the users, keep the door open for the day a budget exists, and move the team's time to a buyer who can decide.

Related

All 25 founder decisions · Forward this to: The champion inside the customer, who needs a reason to bring in the budget owner.

This page was written from an illustrative founder story, "The pilot extension she could answer in her sleep". The characters and events in it are invented; it is not a customer testimonial or an account of a verified GTM Right result.